Prerequisites
- Faceless Butcher in hand or on the battlefield or in exile
- Hostage Taker in hand or on the battlefield or in exile
- Lumbering Battlement in hand or on the battlefield or in exile
plus the mana cost of the creature in your hand available
Steps
- Cast Faceless Butcher for its mana cost
- When Faceless Butcher enters, it exiles Hostage Taker until Faceless Butcher leaves the battlefield
- Resolve any additional effects of Faceless Butcher's ETB
- When Hostage Taker leaves the battlefield, Lumbering Battlement is returned from exile to the battlefield
- When Lumbering Battlement enters, it exiles Faceless Butcher until Lumbering Battlement leaves the battlefield
- Resolve any additional effects of Lumbering Battlement's ETB
- When Faceless Butcher leaves the battlefield, Hostage Taker is returned from exile to the battlefield
- When Hostage Taker enters, it exiles Lumbering Battlement until Hostage Taker leaves the battlefield
- Resolve any additional effects of Hostage Taker's ETB
- When Lumbering Battlement leaves the battlefield, Faceless Butcher is returned from exile to the battlefield
- Repeat from step 2
Results
Required Cards 3

Faceless Butcher
Creature — Nightmare Horror

Hostage Taker
Creature — Human Pirate

Lumbering Battlement
Creature — Beast